Best Apples for Baking & Cooking (Pie, Crisp, Applesauce, Cider)

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Please read our disclosure policy.

This guide breaks down the best apples for baking and cooking, plus which varieties shine in pie, crisp, applesauce, savory dishes, and cider.

Kaleb Wyse wearing a black shirt standing in front of a taupe background.

Apples Are Not One Size Fits All

Walk into the produce section, and it feels simple: grab a bag of apples and call it good. Then you bake a pie, and the filling turns watery. Or your crisp turns into applesauce. Or your sliced apples brown before you sit down.

Here’s the secret: choosing apples is mostly about texture and balance. Once you know what you want your apples to do, picking the right variety gets easy.

Here’s my advice for each type of baking or cooking to help you get the best results.

Basket filled with baking apples sitting on grass.

Quick Guide

Apple Picker Chart

Use this as your guide to pick the correct bag of apples:

If you’re making…	Best apples to use	Why they work
Apple pie	Granny Smith, Honeycrisp, Braeburn, Pink Lady, Jonagold	Firm texture, good flavor, holds shape
Apple crisp or cobbler	Honeycrisp, Granny Smith, Pink Lady, Braeburn	Tender but still sliceable
Baked apples	Honeycrisp, Braeburn, Jonagold, Pink Lady	Softens without collapsing
Applesauce	McIntosh, Golden Delicious, Gala (in a blend)	Breaks down quickly and smoothly
Apple butter	McIntosh and Golden Delicious	Cooks down rich and silky
Salads	Honeycrisp, Fuji, Pink Lady, Jazz, Envy, Cosmic Crisp	Crisp bite, great fresh flavor
Savory cooking	Granny Smith, Braeburn, Jonagold, Honeycrisp	Flavor stands up to herbs and meat
Fresh cider	Mix sweet and tart apples (see blends below)	Balanced sweetness and brightness

What Makes One Apple Better Than Another

Most “best apple” decisions come down to 4 traits:

Firmness – Will it hold its shape, or melt down into sauce?
Sweetness vs tartness – Tart apples keep desserts from tasting flat. Sweet apples caramelize beautifully.
Juiciness – Juicy apples can be amazing, but they can also make pie fillings watery without enough thickener.
Browning speed – Some apples brown faster after slicing, which matters for salads and snack boards.

A general rule of thumb – For pies and crisps, use firm apples and mix varieties for better flavor.

Crisp vs Soft Apples

Crisp, firm apples (hold their shape) – These are your go-to apples for slices and chunks that stay distinct after baking.

Great for – pie, crisp, galette, baked apples, roasting with pork or chicken
Common examples – Honeycrisp, Granny Smith, Pink Lady, Braeburn, Fuji, Cosmic Crisp, Jazz
Drawback – Many crisp apples are firm and will take longer to become tender when cooking or baking.

Softer apples (break down quickly) – These apples cook down fast and turn silky.

Great for – applesauce, apple butter, cooked apple toppings
Common examples – McIntosh, Golden Delicious, Gala (often best in blends)
Drawback – In pies and crisps, they can turn mushy if used alone.

Grocery Store Apple Guide (Benefits & Drawbacks)

Popular types of apples, how they’re best used, plus their benefits and drawbacks:

Type of apple	Details
Granny Smith	Best for – Pies, crisps, and savory dishes Benefits – Very tart and reliably firm. Adds structure and balance to sweet desserts. Drawbacks – On its own, it can taste sharp. Pair it with a sweeter apple for a more rounded flavor.
Honeycrisp	Best for – Crisps, pie blends, salads, and snacking Benefits – Big crunch and bold fresh flavor. Holds up well in the oven. Drawbacks – Very juicy, so pie fillings often need a little extra thickener.
Gala	Best for – Snacking, salads, cakes, muffins, and sauce blends Benefits – Sweet, mild, and widely available. Great “everyday apple.” Drawbacks – Can soften faster in the oven than the best pie apples. Use it in a blend if you want defined slices
Fuji	Best for – Snacking, salads, and baking in a blend Benefits – Sweet, crisp, and sturdy. Great fresh texture. Drawbacks – Can be a little mild once baked. Pair with a more tart apple for more “apple pop.”
Golden Delicious	Best for – Cakes, muffins, pie blends, and applesauce blends Benefits – Classic baked-apple flavor and gentle sweetness. Plays well with warm spices. Drawbacks – Not always firm enough for clean slices in pie unless paired with a sturdier apple.
Pink Lady (Cripps Pink)	Best for – Pies, crisps, galettes, and salads Benefits – Bright sweet-tart flavor, firm texture, and a nice crisp bite. Drawbacks – Can read slightly tart if you prefer very sweet desserts.
Braeburn	Best for – Pies, crisps, and baked apples Benefits – Firm, aromatic, and spice-friendly. Bakes beautifully. Drawbacks – Availability can be inconsistent, depending on the store.
Jonagold	Best for – Pies, crisps, cakes, and chunky applesauce Benefits – Sweet-tart flavor with a fragrant, classic “orchard apple” vibe. Tender but not instantly mushy. Drawbacks – Can soften faster than the firmest varieties, so it’s excellent in blends.
McIntosh	Best for – Applesauce, apple butter, and cooked apple topping Benefits – Breaks down quickly into a smooth, creamy texture with very little effort. Drawbacks – Not a great solo pie apple because it softens fast.
Red Delicious	Best for – Snacking if very fresh Benefits – Easy to find and often inexpensive. Drawbacks – Can lean towards mealy and mild, especially when older. Rarely the best choice for baking.
Cosmic Crisp	Best for – Snacking, salads, and baking in a blend. Benefits – Very crisp, juicy, and sturdy. Great all-around modern grocery option. Drawbacks – Can be extra juicy, so treat it like Honeycrisp in pie fillings.
Jazz	Best for – Salads, snacking, and baking in a blend Benefits – Crunchy with a bright, sweet-tart flavor. Drawbacks – Not always stocked everywhere year-round.
Envy	Best for – Snacking, salads, and cheese boards Benefits – Sweet, crisp, and often slow to brown after slicing. Drawbacks – Usually pricier, and the flavor can be more “sweet” than “baked apple” in desserts.

Some Heirloom Favorites

These often show up at orchards and specialty grocery stores, especially in the fall:

Type of apple	Details
Jonathan	Best for – Pies, crisps, and baking in general Benefits – Sweet-tart flavor that tastes like classic apple desserts. Great aroma. Drawbacks – Can be seasonal and sometimes smaller in size.
Cortland	Best for – Salads, snack trays, and pie blends Benefits – Crisp, bright flavor. Often a solid choice for slicing. Drawbacks – Can soften faster than the firmest pie apples, so pair it with a sturdy variety for baking.
Haralson	Best for – Pies, baking blends, and savory dishes Benefits – Very firm and very tart. Holds shape beautifully and brings bold flavor. Drawbacks – Too tart for some on its own. Blend with sweeter apples.
Wealthy	Best for – Sauces and baking blends Benefits – Old-fashioned flavor that tastes like fall. Drawbacks – Texture can lean softer, so it’s better blended for pies.

Apples For Fresh Cider

Cider uses the same apples but aims for a slightly different balance. There are 3 things that shape cider flavor:

Sugar – sweetness and fermentation potential
Acid – brightness and “zip”
Tannin – structure, depth, and a gentle drying finish (more important for hard cider)

Most grocery store apples bring sugar and acid. Traditional cider apples are prized for their tannin and complexity. But you can still make delicious cider with grocery store apples, using this simple blend:

2 parts sweet – Fuji, Gala, Honeycrisp, Golden Delicious
1 part tart – Granny Smith, Jonathan, Haralson

If you want it a bit brighter, add more tart apples. For a bit sweeter cider, add more Golden Delicious or Gala.

Shopping & Storage Tips

Buy firm apples – Soft spots usually mean bruising and faster breakdown in baking.
Refrigerate for longer storage – Apples last longer and stay crisper when chilled.
Keep them contained – Apples give off a natural ripening gas that can speed up ripening in nearby produce.
Wash right before using – This helps keep apples fresher during storage.